« Tierney On Why Men Compete | Main | INTER-BLOGATORY TRAVEL »

June 01, 2005

Live Aid Redux

Remember Live Aid back in 1985? The feel-good fundraiser for African hunger led by then-Boomtown Rats band leader Bob Geldof (now Sir Bob Geldof)?

Geldof does. According to Chrenkoff, Geldof is planning on a reunion concert series of sorts, along with new acts, as a free "consciousness-raising" concert. He's not looking for money, but is hoping the concerts will induce popular pressure for various countries to relieve third world debt, double aid to the region, and reform trade laws.

That's all well and good. But as Chrenkoff reminds us, the money raised 20 years ago didn't really go to where it was needed. He quotes Daniel Wolf:

90 per cent or more of the aid came from Western donor governments. As the governments would only deal with a recipient government, not with rebel movements, most of the aid - again, roughly 90 per cent - was channelled through Mengistu's hands. In a grotesque irony, we found ourselves supporting the very government that was causing the famine we were supposed to be alleviating.

You really must read the entire post for yourself. As Chrenkoff says, It's so much easier though to have a concert or an appeal for aid or debt forgiveness rather than for political and economic liberty.

Ain't it the truth?

Posted by at June 1, 2005 09:40 AM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.lifelikepundits.com/cgi-bin/mt3/mt-tb.cgi/887

Comments

Who cares about the third world? Let's face it, people get what they deserve.

Posted by: Clete at June 1, 2005 10:44 AM

I remember that when news of how the money & food were not getting to the starving Africans, Geldof was amzed at his own naivete. He sais something to the effect that he thought he would be so easy, that all he had to do was raise the money and that would save the people.

Posted by: kitty at June 1, 2005 11:55 AM

I'd like to see him go out there and try to distribute the aid...then perhaps he'll get a feel for what he's really up against. People whine that the U.S. government is horrible and that we don't do enough for people, but what it really is about is terribly corrupt governments in Africa that don't give a hoot about the little people...all they care about is power. Sorry, but when was the last time we had a famine here?

Posted by: Pam M. at June 1, 2005 02:16 PM

We don't have famine's here because we have US Dollars. But an awful lot of our meat and produce now comes from abroad. All it would take is for the dollar to drop another 20% or so and the community food banks will be empty. The ones up here are strained now.
Of course you'd have to call the dust bowl years in the early thirties a famine. A lot of farm land was suddenly unproductive and people were starving to death. And we didn't have a civil war to blame it on.

Posted by: IaintBacchus at June 1, 2005 06:02 PM

I'm always checking on the source of the meat & produce I buy, and most of it is produced in the USA. I live in NY State, so during the winter I'll see more produce from Chile, but still most of it comes from the South.

Posted by: kitty at June 1, 2005 06:35 PM

While it's true that we did have the dust bowl in the '30s, that was an unfortunate natural phenomenon...drought. And drought can happen anytime, anywhere. What's happening in parts of Africa is more often due to brutal governments, rather than natural phenomonon or even poor farming methods. For example, in Zimbabwe, Robert Mugabe forced white farmers off of their farms in order to "redistribute" the land to "rightful" black owners. However, he pretty much gave it to friends and relatives, forcing black workers off the land as well as the white owners. His political party has burned millions of acres of farmland and prevented the farming of millions more. Combined with drought, this has caused tremendous food shortages, poverty and starvation in a country that used to export its grain.

Ethiopia is again facing famine partly because of drought and fires, and partly because the government is corrupt and inefficient.

No, we didn't have civil war to blame for the dust bowl. But our government (the Dems were in charge at the time) wasn't to blame for it either. Raising money for African countries and forgiving their debt is a noble concept. However, as long as corrupt governments reign, it's pretty much throwing money down the sewer, because it won't get to those who really need it. And if the governments there don't change, what then?

Posted by: Pam M. at June 1, 2005 09:02 PM

Post a Comment




Remember Me?